Friday, February 21, 2025

Providing feedback is one of the most powerful tools for reinforcing positive behavior and correcting areas that need improvement. Every time we give feedback, we have one of two goals: to encourage someone to continue doing something well or to guide them in changing an existing behavior. To achieve this goal, our feedback must be clear, actionable, and delivered in a way that is most likely to motivate the person to meet the standard.
Our CBIA Feedback model is highly effective in each of these areas, and is the first place we start to create impactful feedback and accountability with teams. These principles take the effectiveness of CBIA to the next level.
1. Feedback Should Be Frequent, Specific, and Timely
You’re hired into a new role. You complete the onboarding, and get to work. After turning in a few reports, you get an email back that says “great work,” so you start feeling like you’re getting the hang of things. Another few weeks go buy, and you run into your supervisor in the elevator. They casually mention “you need to be more proactive in meetings.” You haven’t been in a meeting with that supervisor in a while, so you aren’t quite sure what that means, but you decide you’ll speak up more.
Finally, you get to an annual review, expecting things to be ok. You’re blindsided by a negative review that cites your behavior as argumentative in a meeting three months ago.
Even if all that feedback was true at every step of the way, it was never delivered in a way that was clear, actionable, or motivating. The supervisor did not set you up for success.
Don’t be that supervisor! Consider the feedback you are giving to your team with these three questions:
• Is it timely? Address the behavior soon after it happens. Don’t leave people guessing!
• Is it frequent? Don't reserve feedback for performance reviews; make it a regular practice.
• Is it specific? Vague feedback like “good job” isn’t as helpful as “I appreciated how you handled that difficult meeting with patience and clarity.”
These don’t have to be huge conversations, you can combine these principles in quick conversation moments like these:
• Timely and Specific: After a meeting, a supervisor tells an employee, "I really liked how you summarized the key action items at the end. It kept everyone on track—let’s keep doing that."
• Frequent and Actionable: A manager checks in weekly with a new employee, providing guidance on project expectations and offering praise for meeting deadlines efficiently.
• Immediate and Constructive: A supervisor notices an error in a report and immediately addresses it: "I see there's an inconsistency in these data points. Let’s correct it now, and for future reports, double-check calculations before submission."
2. Praise Progress, Not Just Perfection
Waiting for someone to be perfect before giving positive feedback is counterproductive. Acknowledging progress encourages continued effort. Even if an employee hasn’t fully met the standard yet, recognizing improvement keeps them motivated.
For example, if someone is habitually late to meetings but improves from being 30 minutes late to 15 minutes late, it might feel strange to say, “Great job, you were only 15 minutes late!” Why would I congratulate them on failing? You aren’t! You’re encouraging them to continue to put in effort to get better.
Let’s shift to the other perspective. Your team has struggled to stay under a 30% vacancy rate. No matter how hard you try, your team is underwater with all the extra work. You’re working harder than ever, but it’s impossible to get everything done the same way you did when the team was fully staffed.
What would it be like if every meeting with your supervisor was the same conversation of “this was late, this data wasn’t right, you’re behind on that report, etc., etc., etc.”? That may be clear feedback, but it isn’t reasonably actionable with your current resources, and it DEFINITELY isn’t motivating. At what point do you just give up? Why work harder if no one seems to care about the difference it makes?
What if instead your supervisor said this: "I see you're making a real effort to meet deadlines, and I appreciate it. I know things are difficult with our staffing right now. Let’s keep working to not fall too far behind while we work on staffing up."
For most people, that’s much more motivating.
When giving your team feedback, focus on any improvement they are making toward a goal. Encourage that effort so they eventually turn that into positive results.
3. Encourage After Honest Mistakes
People need encouragement the most after they make an honest mistake. If someone is genuinely trying and fails, your response should be constructive: “That didn’t go as planned, but what can we learn from this? How can we avoid this next time?”
If they realize the error, and own it, this is the time to coach them back up.
Said another way, don’t kick someone while they’re down.
4. Maintain a Healthy Ratio of Positive to Corrective Feedback
Research varies on the suggested ratio of positive to corrective feedback ranges from 3:1 to 11:1. Essentially, everyone agrees when we give people more positive feedback than corrective feedback, they tend to perform better over time. We just don’t know exactly how much more positive feedback that is.
In our experience, 11:1 is a pipedream. Making time to give feedback is critical, but it shouldn’t become your whole job. 3:1 is a great goal to shoot for, but even if you end up at 2:1, that’s better than 1:1, or even 1:2.
That means for every corrective piece of feedback, you should strive to give at least three pieces of positive reinforcement. The reason for this is pretty obvious when we take a minute to think about it.
If you work for someone, and every time they give you feedback on your work they point out everything you’re doing wrong, how would you feel? About them? About your work?
Most people would start to get the message that no matter what they do right, no effort they put in really matters. Why try hard to perform well when the end result is always the same – a giant list of things you aren’t good at.
But what if you get some positive feedback one day. Then some more the next morning, and something else that afternoon. On Day 3, your boss comes to you and say “the way you did this doesn’t work, I need it to be more like this.”
Now how do you feel? Most people are not only way less defensive when they get that feedback, they are already motivated to want to correct that thing. They want to get back on the positive feedback train.
Constant negative attention suffocates motivation. It doesn’t matter how “correct” your feedback is, if it is all negative, you will see a huge drop off in performance with most people.
(Side note: something like 2% of people are so intrinsically motivated they don’t care how much criticism they get, as long as it’s valid. They even thrive in harsh environments that push them to be excellent. If you have one of these people, you’ll know. For everyone else, this ratio matters a lot.)
So what does this mean for leaders? A couple things –
First, to be able to give more positive feedback means we need to be actively looking for things people are doing right. Most of us have waaaay more responsibility than we have bandwidth in our jobs. We are always thinking about the next thing we need to do, and we can easily get tunnel vision in our work.
We get snapped out of that state easily when people make mistakes; they show up with bright flashing neon signs that we can’t even ignore if we try. We don’t tend to pay attention to things people do that are good, or even great. Someone has to do something completely and unexpectedly incredible to really grab our attention.
So to get even close to a 3:1 ratio, we need to intentionally scout for data that we can use for positive feedback. We need to be proactively looking for what people do well. If we don’t, we will always be playing from behind, and will be slowly suffocating our team’s motivation.
Second, we need to be very intentional about the corrective feedback we give. If we need to hit a 3:1 ratio, don’t waste the “1” on something that is mildly irritating. Use it on something that really matters! Focus your corrective feedback on behaviors that will have the highest return on investment.
Don’t point out every flaw. Point out the flaw that, if corrected, will pay the most dividends moving forward. Get as close to the root cause of an issue, and start giving corrective feedback about that behavior.
To refer back to #1, when we can remember to give more of those quick hit positive feedback moments, we build the trust and relationship to be prepared for the larger corrective feedback conversations when they really matter.
5. Avoid the “Compliment Sandwich”
What was initially a well thought out way to develop others has become a misunderstood and overused formula that now does more harm than good.
The “compliment sandwich” model of positive-negative-positive goes back to the 1940s military and corporate training materials, but was most formalized by the esteemed Peter Drucker in the 50’s and 60’s. It became a standard in most corporate trainings after the 1971 book Management of Organizational Behavior by Paul Hersey and Kenneth Blanchard.
Drucker’s philosophy of feedback was to start with a person’s strength to appropriately build their confidence, address areas for growth and improvement to show them a path forward, and end with forward looking potential results to motivate them to continue working hard. This strength-development-motivation model was much closer to the CBIA model that we recommend than the compliment sandwich it was diluted to by the mid 1980’s.
As it is commonly used today, the “compliment sandwich” delivery of negative feedback sandwiched between two positives is ineffective at best, and damaging at worst. The reason comes from one of the most widely known psychological studies of all time – Pavlov’s dog. This observation and subsequent experiment showed that dogs didn’t just salivate when they saw food, they salivate when experience other stimuli (seeing the lab assistant that normally feeds them, hearing a bell that usually rings during feeding time) that they have learned over time are associated with getting food. This is called classical conditioning.
When we experience two things together consistently, after time we are “conditioned” to associate those to things with each other. So, if every time I get feedback from my supervisor it starts good, then gets bad, I will be conditioned to brace for bad news every time I get a compliment. After a while, I don’t even hear the compliments, I just brace for what I know is coming next.
People learn to expect bad news every time they hear a compliment, which makes them tune out positive reinforcement. Instead, provide direct and honest feedback without unnecessary sugarcoating.
Clear, Actionable, Motivating
Great feedback is an essential tool for guiding the personal and professional growth of your team. Find a model that works for you to give feedback that is clear and actionable, and use these 5 practices to deliver that feedback in a way that is more motivating. Over time we think you will be amazed at the difference you see in your team.
This training series will give your team all the skills they need for setting professional boundaries and more.
